This post was updated, edited and added to on February 21, 2023 after listening to a podcast about tithing. I had so much more to say and felt the need to just edit instead of making a whole new post.
So let me tell you a little about my tithing experience in the church.
I'm sure reading the first few posts have gotten you thinking "she probably never even had a true testimony of tithing" or "she doesn't understand the reason for tithing"
That's completely wrong. I had a very strong testimony of tithing. I have been (up until 2021) a very faithful tithe paying member. When I was a child if I got a dime for doing something around the house or my mom had given me her pocket change I would pay tithing on that dime. There were weeks when as an 8yo I would hand the bishop a tithing envelope with a penny in it and know I was doing what the Lord wanted me to.
Once I started having kids I'd write the tithing check and have them go deliver the envelope to the bishopric to teach them how important it was to pay that tithing. All my life I had wondered if we were supposed to pay tithing on our gross or our net income. The answer I always got from leadership was "do you want gross or net blessings?"...obviously gross!
When we moved to Illinois in 2006, we were so poor. We had to pay for two households since my husband came to Illinois and lived in an apartment while we stayed in California to sell our home. We had exactly $250 in our bank account and the house payment and rent were coming due but that money was our tithing money. I put it in an envelope and went to the mail box to send it to the Bishop. I stood at the mailbox for 10 minutes trying to decide if mailing this was the right thing. Back and forth KNOWING that was all the money we had and I didn't have any groceries either. I hesitantly put the envelope in the mailbox and walked away crying.
That evening Chris called me and told me that his company had given him a $2500 moving bonus that day and we could pay the bills and buy food. BAM I was hooked. Paying my tithing had paid off 10 fold! There was no way I was ever going to question or hesitate paying that tithing again.
Now moving to Illinois was very stressful. We left all our family behind in California, I had never lived in another state and we had 3 small children. Also our finances weren't as good as we had hoped and while we had enough for our bills and home we didn't have a lot for food or any extras. After a few years (all the while paying thousands in tithing every year) we had 3 more children and the budget was even tighter. The food situation was getting grim, to the point I went to bed hungry a lot because I let the kids have the extra or larger portions. I finally broke down and applied for government food assistance. This was such a blessing for us. We had plenty finally for our needs. However this came at a price. The price being my self worth. It was humiliating to me that we needed to use assistance. I would pull out my card at the store and swipe it as fast as I could in case anyone saw me. I NEVER mentioned it to anyone, not my parents, not even our own kids. I worked a few part time jobs in the evenings, I did daycare in our home and even tried teaching sewing lessons and starting my own business to make ends meet. Still we struggled. I was too ashamed to go and ask the ward for assistance. If I had needed them to buy groceries there would have been some of my friends in the loop that the Clark's had no food and they would be in charge of judging what we needed each time we had a grocery need. I couldn't do that. I couldn't go to church and know that my friends were that included in my families finances. It was humiliating.
There were 2 times when we needed to ask the church for assistance for paying our house payment and both times the Bishops gave us a hard time...as full tithe payers they gave us a hard time about needing assistance twice in the last 30 years...hmmm... Each time we asked them it was during times when I or my husband had major medical issues which required extended stays in the hospital and loss of wages.
Fast forward to 2021/2022, I had 2 children come out to me as LGBTQ. I knew that I would support them with all my everything. I came across an article, I don't remember where I'm positive it was a "church approved source" since there was no way at this point that I was going to look at "anti" sources. It talked about BYU being subsidized by the church and tithing money. This gave me huge pause as I had also heard stories and read articles about BYU and their anti gay policies and programs. How could I pay to a church that supported these institutions that actively hurt my kids. After this realization I went down a rabbit hole of other things the church pays for with tithing and was completely shocked. Prop 8 in California, multi million dollar temples, legislation stopping LGBTQ rights from passing, salaries for the general authorities the list goes on. I knew I had to stop paying tithing immediately. I needed my limited funds to go to better places that kept my kids safe and were more in line with my beliefs in human rights and social issues.
A few months after I stopped paying tithing our Bishop came to our home to do temple recommend interviews. I was blindsided by this meeting as my husband didn't tell me this was what the bishop was coming for and I had not discussed with my hubs about my lack of paying tithing. I had, at that time, a small part time job and my own small bank account I paid from on my own. My husband was not attending and had not been attending church for 7 years prior. (we had kept up on tithing until this point). During the interview I answered ALL the other questions honestly and correctly. I had a testimony, I sustained the leaders, I believed the brethren to be prophets, I am honest, I kept the word of wisdom, I am chaste, I believed the Book of Mormon to be the word of God. ALL the other questions were perfect, then the tithing one came up and I answered honestly. I told the Bishop that I could not in good conscience donate to an institution that actively fought against and hurt my family but I still did donate my funds to other places that I felt better aligned with my beliefs.
When he told me right then that he could not give me that recommend a huge lightbulb went off in my brain. I had to pay the church for my temple blessings, for my salvation, I had to pay the church for my family to be together forever. I know lots of people would say "it's about obedience to God not the money" but I was obedient. I had prayed about this and gotten personal revelation that what I was doing in NOT paying tithing was the right thing to do. I also know from other friends of mine who have lost their temple recommends that our stake president had a habit of looking up our tithing amounts and if they didn't seem to him like they could be 10% of your income he'd deny recommends even if you answered the question in the affirmative. So I knew that I had no chance to even say "yes I pay" even though I was technically paying to other places.
This brings up a huge point. All my life I was taught that giving our money to charities other than the church was dangerous because they used most of their donations to fund the operations of those charities. Very little of the money goes to actually helping people. This is complete and utter garbage since we know the church is worth hundreds of billions of dollars and gives less that 1 billion to charity...math don't math. I'm required to give 10% of my income to the church but the church gives way less than 10% of it's income to help others. Nope, not gonna fall for that again.
Another huge issue for me now is the fact that as members we are taught to have as many children as God will give us. Doesn't matter your financial, physical or emotional state. Have those kids and also give us 10% of your income.
Another question is why is tithing connected to temple attendance? Well temple attendance is the highest form of worship we have in the church. It's the main goal of everyone in attendance. It's how we get to keep our families, it's how we save our ancestors, it's how we heal people and show love and learn how to get into Heaven. So let's make giving the church money a requirement to get into the temple to receive all these blessings, it's kind of brilliant. Now they have a guaranteed stream of income from followers who WANT those blessings and promises. Kind of genius. Mostly disgusting.
I also found out the prices that the church will pay for temples. Millions of dollars per temple. We are talking hundreds of thousands of dollars on the carpet for each temple...CARPET! Hundreds of thousands on ONE chandelier...ONE! When I think of all the people that they could clothe and feed it literally makes me sick. Even all the hours I spent in the temple when I could have been helping actual LIVING people or spending time with my LIVING children. Maybe lets focus on the issues living breathing suffering people are having instead of issues that we maybe think our dead are having. What would God want us to focus more on?
Another point I want to make is the way the church makes you feel that by paying your tithing you're somehow better off. Like if you didn't pay them the 10% of your income you'd be more destitute...I really believed that if I stopped paying tithing I would have less money. That's how indoctrinated I was. I believed that it wasn't my money in the first place, it was God's, and that I was somehow indebted to him so I needed to give that money to the church. I look back now and just sigh in disbelief that my brain was so washed that I did these things with blind obedience. It took my children suffering for me to understand.
Since stopping paying tithing things have been so much better. Not perfect but better. We still struggle sometimes with emergency things that come up as we don't save like we should. However my husbands income has almost doubled in the last year and a half. Our business does well, We are still "blessed" even though we do not give away 10% of our funds to a church that misuses them. Yes, I said misuses them because after I wrote this I found out about the church's criminal behavior which led to an SEC investigation and fines of $5,000,000. So they are intentionally hiding money from the government and also not reporting it to the members. Maybe they should have their temple recommends revoked too. Goose/Gander situation.
The Bishop then asked if I thought I'd like to maybe start paying again to get that recommend and that was a HARD PASS. The damage had been done. If I had not had this experience with tithing I would not have done any other research about the problematic issues of the church. I would today still be a full member in good standing. So maybe I should be thanking him, because without the question of tithing in my brain I would not have discovered that it's all just a big hoax anyway.
The church is not a charitable institution it is a corporation. Big difference.